Art Case Update: counterfeit imports, Northern Song sculptures and restitution reform

Photo credit: Photo by ST Mathew on Unsplash

Aurelian Lawyers & Advisers is your go-to source for art-related legal cases and law reform in Australia, as well as select cases internationally.

In this edition, Principal and Founder Alana Kushnir and Lawyer Sarah Wei consider a High Court decision on remedies for trespass involving copyright footage, the Full Court’s packaging-copyright analysis, new counterfeit-import enforcement measures, the return of two Northern Song sculptures to China, South Korea’s phased art-market reforms and Italy’s proposed restitution framework.

 

Australia

National Gallery of Australia returns two Northern Song sculptures to China

On 28 October 2026, the National Gallery of Australia handed two Northern Song dynasty (960–1127) limestone sculptural heads to China’s National Cultural Heritage Administration at the Gallery in Canberra. The works depict a civil official and a military official. Gallery research associates them with the Yongchang and Yongyu imperial mausoleums near Gongyi in Henan Province; their precise removal and ownership history before 1995 remains undocumented.

The Gallery received the sculptures from a private collector in 1995. Its records describe their earlier location, ownership and transfer as unknown. In 2015, volunteer guide Janet Smith identified a possible connection after consulting a 1991 publication about sculptures lining the mausoleums’ “spirit roads”. The Gallery subsequently compared the works with figures remaining at the sites and reported corresponding stylistic and physical features. That research informed discussions with Chinese authorities, followed by a formal request for return in 2025.

The return illustrates why provenance review should continue after acquisition. New publications, archives and comparative research can change what is known about a work held for decades. Collectors and institutions should preserve acquisition records, record gaps and degrees of certainty, and assess legal, ethical and diplomatic considerations before making public claims about origin or ownership.

Handover source (Embassy of the People’s Republic of China in Australia)

 

New penalties for importing goods bearing false trade marks

The Customs Legislation Amendment (False Trade Marks Infringement Notices) Act 2026 (Cth) received Royal Assent on 20 May 2026. The Act is scheduled to commence automatically on 20 November 2026. It creates a new strict liability offence for importing goods that bear false trade marks, i.e. goods that infringe a registered trade mark, known more commonly as counterfeits or pirate goods.

Until now, illegal importers could simply forfeit their counterfeit goods and profit if they were found or detected. With the new law Australian Border Force (ABF) have the power to issue infringement notices instead of prosecuting. For an infringement notice penalties can reach up to 15 penalty units for an individual (~AU$5,460) or 75 penalty units for a company (~AU$27,300). For each offence prosecution can reach a maximum of 60 penalty units (~A$21,840) for an individual or 75 penalty units (~A$109,200) for a company

The new infringement notice penalties are designed to work alongside the existing Notice of Objection scheme under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). Under that scheme, a trade mark owner can lodge a notice that allows the ABF to detain and seize imported goods suspected of infringing the registered mark.

Practical implications: Artists, galleries, designers and luxury businesses that own or are authorised to use registered marks should consider whether a Notice of Objection forms part of their border-enforcement strategy and keep its coverage current. Importers should verify suppliers and retain licences, consents and other records showing why branded goods are authorised. The reform targets goods bearing false trade marks; it does not prohibit parallel imports or every import bearing a registered mark.

Official sources: Act

 

High Court refuses constructive trust over copyright in trespass footage 

On 11 November 2026, the High Court delivered judgment in Farm Transparency International Limited v The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd [2026] HCA 42. The Court comprised Gageler CJ and Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ. The appeal concerned equitable remedies for harm flowing from footage created during trespasses—not whether the land occupier automatically owned copyright in that footage.

Background

The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd (Game Meats) operates a licensed halal abattoir at Eurobin, Victoria. Farm Transparency International Limited (Farm Transparency), a charity focused on animal protection, entered the property without permission on several occasions between 9 January and 13 April 2024, installed hidden cameras and later retrieved them.

Farm Transparency compiled a 14-minute film, supplied it to the Commonwealth agriculture department and Minister and to Channel Seven, and briefly published it on its website before an interlocutory injunction. The primary judge awarded Game Meats $30,000 in general damages and $100,000 in exemplary damages for trespass, but declined to impose a constructive trust over copyright or grant final publication and deletion orders. The Full Court later declared that Farm Transparency held the copyright on constructive trust for Game Meats and made consequential assignment, restraint, deletion and disclosure orders.

The decision

All seven Justices agreed on the orders, although their reasons differed. The High Court:

·       set aside the declaration of constructive trust and the related assignment, continuing-publication and disclosure orders;

·       ordered Farm Transparency to delete or destroy the images and copies in its possession or control, including copies later returned to its possession or control;

·       required Farm Transparency to provide an affidavit confirming compliance within 14 days; and

·       restrained Farm Transparency from publishing the images until it complied with the deletion order.

Why equitable relief remained available

1.     Connection to the trespass. The relevant threatened harm arose from Farm Transparency’s proposed further use of images created through its trespasses, rather than from the mere existence of copyright.

2.     Damages were inadequate. Because the extent of possible future use could not be known, the damages award did not fully address the threatened ongoing harm. That supported targeted equitable relief.

3.     Relief had to remain proportionate. Orders could bind Farm Transparency and require deletion of material within its possession or control. They could not determine the rights or liabilities of recipients and other non-parties who had not been heard.

Why the constructive trust mattered

A constructive trust arises by operation of law rather than agreement. If imposed over copyright, it can separate legal title from beneficial ownership and support an order transferring the copyright. Because that proprietary remedy can affect more than the immediate wrongdoer, it requires a principled basis and careful attention to third-party interests.

As maker of the footage, Farm Transparency owned copyright under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). Game Meats sought beneficial ownership and assignment so that it could control reproduction and communication of the images. As Gageler CJ and Gleeson J observed, control of the images was “the prize”.

That remedy would have enabled Game Meats to rely on copyright against recipients and potential publishers who were not parties to the proceeding. The Court treated those consequences as important when assessing whether proprietary relief was justified.

The separate reasons placed different emphasis on equity’s response. Jagot J stressed that copyright and infringement are creatures of the Copyright Act and that the statutory framework matters when equity is asked to redirect ownership. Other members of the Court focused on the established categories of institutional constructive trust, the exceptional character of remedial constructive trusts, proportionality and the position of non-parties.

Why the High Court refused a constructive trust over copyright

1.     No institutional constructive trust arose. Gordon, Edelman and Steward JJ reasoned that the case did not fall within an established category in which beneficial ownership arises automatically. Copyright was created by Farm Transparency’s act of filming; it was not property taken from Game Meats.

2.     A remedial constructive trust was not necessary. The judges’ routes differed, but the availability of orders directed to Farm Transparency—including deletion—meant that transferring copyright was not required to do justice between the parties.

3.    Third-party consequences mattered. The proposed transfer would have armed Game Meats with statutory rights against people and organisations that were not before the Court. The Court did not decide whether any particular third party had infringed copyright or could lawfully publish the footage.

Practical implications

The decision confirms that a court may grant targeted equitable relief where damages do not adequately address threatened harm connected with trespass. It does not establish that an occupier owns copyright in footage made during a trespass, nor does it decide the publication rights or liabilities of third parties. Rights holders, media organisations, activists and institutions should assess copyright, confidentiality, property and injunction risks separately rather than assume that unlawfully obtained material has a single legal status.

The Court’s reasons leave the availability of proprietary relief to the requirements of a future case. The result should not be read as a general rule that every person who records during a trespass must delete the material, or that every third party remains free to publish it: both questions depend on the facts, the pleaded causes of action and the orders sought.

Official case page

 

Full Court clarifies the substantial-part test for packaging artwork

In its 19 August 2026 judgment in Aldi Foods Pty Limited v Hampden Holdings I.P. Pty Limited [2026] FCAFC 103, the Full Court of the Federal Court considered the LITTLE BELLIES and Aldi MAMIA children’s snack packaging.

Hampden Holdings I.P. Pty Limited and Lacorium Health Australia Pty Limited own copyright in packaging artwork used for the BABY BELLIES, LITTLE BELLIES and MIGHTY BELLIES ranges. Aldi sold 11 competing MAMIA packaging designs. Its design process used Bellies products as benchmarks while instructing designers to remain “not too close”.

At first instance, Moshinsky J found that three Aldi puff-packaging works infringed copyright and that eight did not: Hampden Holdings I.P. Pty Ltd v Aldi Foods Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 1452. Aldi appealed and the copyright owners cross-appealed. The Full Court comprised Burley, Moore and Owens JJ. The Court found that five of the 11 MAMIA works infringed.

 The central question was whether each Aldi work reproduced a “substantial part” of the relevant copyright work for the purposes of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). Substantiality is qualitative: the court asks whether the part taken embodies features that are important to the originality of the copyright work, not merely how much was copied.

What the Court corrected

·       The Full Court cautioned against defining the allegedly copied part only as a list of general ideas or visual features, such as a small cartoon character with a large, light-coloured belly. Abstraction at too high a level can obscure how those elements are expressed and how the works differ.

·       A side-by-side comparison remains necessary, but it is not a search for overall impression alone. It requires a qualitative, multifaceted assessment of the relevant similarities and differences, the selection and arrangement of features, the originality of what was taken and the relationship between the alleged copy and the particular copyright work.

What it didn’t change

Applying that approach, the Full Court found that five MAMIA packaging works infringed—two more than at first instance. The Court also upheld the finding of flagrant infringement and the basis for additional damages. Aldi’s deliberate benchmarking, access to the Bellies works and management of copying risk were relevant in context; the instruction to remain “not too close” did not, by itself, answer whether the resulting conduct was flagrant.

The decision does not establish that “look and feel” is always irrelevant. Rather, impressionistic resemblance or a list of general concepts cannot substitute for analysis of the protectable expression in each work. Similarities and relevant differences must both be evaluated as part of the substantial-part inquiry.

Practical implications: Artists and brand owners should identify the original expressive choices said to have been taken. Designers, retailers and luxury businesses should document independent development and legal review, but process instructions alone will not prevent infringement or additional damages if the resulting work reproduces a substantial part and the conduct warrants an additional award.

Official judgment

 

International

South Korea’s Art Promotion Act enters its next phase

South Korea’s Art Promotion Act was enacted in 2023 and has commenced in phases. Its general provisions took effect on 26 July 2024; business-reporting provisions commenced on 26 July 2026; and the artist’s resale right in Article 24 is scheduled to commence on 26 July 2027.

What happened

From 26 July 2026, operators within six prescribed categories of art-service business must report specified business information to the competent local government. The categories cover art sales and galleries, auctions, art leasing and sales, art advisory or planning services, appraisal and exhibition-related services. The obligation is a regulatory report or notification—not a general approval of each transaction—and includes prescribed updates when reported particulars change.

The Ministry has described the first year of the reporting regime as a guidance or settling-in period. Market participants should not treat that administrative approach as changing the statutory commencement date and should confirm the filing requirements that apply to their activities. 

The Act also regulates specified unfair practices, including certain abuses of superior bargaining position and unjustified demands for transfers of intellectual property rights. Contract terms and conduct remain important: the legislation does not make every rights assignment or negotiated commercial advantage unlawful.

 Resale royalty

Article 24 is scheduled to apply from 26 July 2027 where a qualifying art-market professional—including a gallery, auction business, art adviser or art leasing and sales business—participates as seller, buyer or intermediary in a qualifying resale. Exceptions include transactions below ₩5 million and specified resales within three years after direct acquisition from the artist where the resale price is below ₩20 million.

The Act’s reciprocity provision means a foreign artist’s entitlement may depend on whether the artist’s home country gives comparable resale-right protection to Korean artists. Australia has its own resale royalty scheme, but reciprocity and eligibility should be checked rather than assumed because the two regimes are not identical.

Practical implications

Galleries, auction houses, advisers, appraisers and other businesses operating in South Korea should identify their category, filing authority and change-reporting obligations. Parties preparing for resales from July 2027 should allocate responsibility for royalty information, payment and records in their transaction documents, and confirm the treatment of foreign artists and statutory exceptions.

  

Italy considers a framework for Holocaust-era art restitution

Italy’s Chamber of Deputies is examining Bill C.2834, a proposal that would delegate the Government to establish a national framework for claims concerning art and cultural property taken from Jewish owners through seizure, looting or forced or distressed transfers linked to Nazi and Fascist persecution. The bill has not been enacted and remains under committee examination.

If enacted in its current form, the delegation would provide for a five-member specialist committee with legal, historical and technical expertise. The committee would examine claims and conduct investigations concerning works in private collections and public institutions, including museums and galleries. It could recommend return to an entitled claimant and, where a taking is established but no claimant can be identified, allocation to a designated Jewish cultural institution identified by the legislation.

The proposal would require the delegated legislation to address procedural barriers, including limitation issues, and the interaction between restitution and Italy’s Cultural Heritage and Landscape Code. A returned work could be released from specified heritage restrictions so that restitution is effective, including where export would otherwise be restricted. Where physical return is unavailable or inappropriate, the framework could allow agreed or recommended alternatives, including monetary compensation or other just and fair solutions.

Bill C.2834 is under examination by the Chamber of Deputies’ VII Committee (Culture, Science and Education). Its text may change and, even if Parliament approves the delegation, implementing legislative measures would still be required. Collectors, dealers, advisers and institutions with works that passed through Italy or continental Europe during the Nazi and Fascist era should preserve provenance records, identify material gaps and monitor the bill, without assuming that a claim or outcome is predetermined.

Official bill record

 

Hans Arp sculpture stolen from Art Cologne

A bronze sculpture by Jean (Hans) Arp, S’élevant (1962), priced at €145,000, was stolen from Galerie Ludorff’s stand at Art Cologne on 8 November 2026. The small work reportedly disappeared within a 15-minute period, prompting a police investigation and an appeal for information. The incident highlights security and insurance considerations for galleries exhibiting portable, high-value artworks at fairs.

Read more here.

 

Miami dealer sentenced over forged Warhols

Miami art dealer Leslie Roberts was sentenced to 46 months in federal prison in October 2026 for his role in selling forged artworks attributed to Andy Warhol. The scheme involved false invoices and fabricated authentication materials used to misrepresent the works’ authenticity. The case underscores the importance of independent authentication and provenance checks, particularly where supporting documentation is supplied by the seller.

Read more here.

 

French court orders restitution of Pissarro sold at Sotheby’s

On 5 November 2026, a Paris court ruled in favour of heirs seeking the return of a Camille Pissarro painting confiscated during the Nazi occupation of France and sold at Sotheby’s London in 2024. The court held that the wartime dispossession undermined subsequent transfers and ordered Sotheby’s to identify the purchaser. The decision highlights continuing restitution risks in cross-border sales, although appeal and enforcement questions may remain.

Read more here.

 

EU considers lower money-laundering risk rating for art trade

The European Commission is reportedly considering lowering its money-laundering and terrorist-financing risk assessment for the art and antiques trade from ‘high’ to ‘moderate’. The reassessment has not yet been finalised and would not remove existing or forthcoming compliance duties. Under the EU’s 2024 anti-money-laundering reforms, relevant obligations for regulated art-market participants are due to apply from July 2027.

Read more here.

Next
Next

The Interview with Dr Carina Popovici of Art Recognition